Forthcoming A31 Brightwells Access Works

Image 2 A

Farnham town centre is about to undergo a considerable amount of disruption caused by building and redevelopment work starting shortly. Brightwells has planning permission although a number of new applications are being processed by Waverley seeking permission to make some changes to the approved proposals. Major works could start at the Woolmead and possibly at the Hopfields in the autumn.

Preparatory works for the Brightwells Development have already started, trees cut down next to the A31 east bound carriageway to allow access from the bypass. It is envisaged that this works will take 12 to 14 weeks and involve the closing of the inside east bound lane of the A31 dual carriageway bypass. A further lane closure is programmed at the completion of the development, likely to be 8 to 10 weeks.

We have identified the following likely problems:

  1. Closure of the inside lane from the Firgrove Hill Bridge through the Hickleys Corner traffic signals to beyond the construction site for 24 hours during the two periods.

  2. Some re-adjustment of the traffic signal phasing at Hickleys Corner. There can be only a small change in timings because of the high existing traffic flows from Station Hill and from the Town Centre.

  3. The major problem will be the capacity of the traffic signals at Hickleys Corner. These operate on a sophisticated program which minimises the overall delay to traffic on all approaches. Recent counts by traffic engineers for the developers gave an morning peak flow eastbound entry flow on the A31 of 1,361 vehicles per hour (vph) [approximately 22 vehicles per minute] and an eastbound exit flow of 1811vph [approximately 30 vehicles per minute]. This latter number includes the traffic exiting South Street onto the Bypass eastbound and that exiting Station Hill onto the Bypass eastbound. The mid morning flows are nearly as high.

  4. The junction already operates at very nearly full capacity and it is not possible to reduce this by some 40% with single lane usage without very serious consequences.

  5. If the signal timings are changed it should be practical to reduce this capacity reduction to about 30%.

  6. Traffic flows from Station Hill onto the A31 should be similar to that at present but if there is no change in the traffic signal timings and that the single lane A31 eastbound from Hickleys Corner is not congested. If the signal timings are changed there would be a drop of about 10% in the traffic flow.

  7. Some longer distance through traffic will divert to other routes, A3, M3 etc but much of the traffic on the A31 is local and long delays, queues and frustration for drivers is likely to become more common.

  8. It is not possible to estimate how long the delays will likely be but many members and residents people are aware of long delays whenever there is one lane closed for grass cutting or other highway works and this is always carried out outside the peak periods. Delays of 20 or 30 minutes are not uncommon.

  9. Delays on the bypass nearly always have an immediate effect on the town centre. Gridlock has occurred repeatedly and recently when there was only a single lane for A31 eastbound traffic through the Shepherd and Flock traffic signals.

  10. We reluctantly envisage the town centre being gridlocked more frequently and for it to occur for long periods throughout the day.

  11. In essence you cannot put a quart into a pint pot without an overflow. ‘Overflow’ in this case will be drivers seeking alternative routes around north and south Farnham, through the town centre, or a lack of trips into Farnham.

Measures that could reduce the impact could be:

  1. Drivers should be encouraged by traffic signing to enter and exit Farnham via Firgrove Hill and Longbridge.

  2. New signage on the A31 and A325 stating: ‘Major works will take place from date X to date Y on the A31 Bypass eastbound. Do not divert into town centre’.

  3. Signs on A31 and A325 stating: ‘Town centre is for local traffic only and no through traffic. This could be controlled and implemented by number plate recognition cameras but is unlikely to be progressed.

  4. Control of the construction traffic timings so that major HGV movements from the Brightwells Development and Woolmead are not at the same time.

  5. All parking for construction vehicles on the Brightwells site must be within then site itself.

  6. Any changes coming from the proposed pedestrianisation or Town Centre Regeneration scheme are introduced after the completion of Brightwells and The Woolmead.

Robert Mansfield

9 May 2018

Click here for full report

3 thoughts on “Forthcoming A31 Brightwells Access Works

  1. • Say Yes to the Appropriate Development of East Street – Myles Harfield
    http://www.facebook.com/groups/385829344786794/permalink/1686983728004676/?comment_id=1687000018003047&comment_tracking=%7B%22tn%22%3A%22R%22%7D

    Not sure they have listed all the potential issues.

    For example, all construction traffic using the A31 bridge will be east bound.

    The lorries will originate in the east (coming over the Hogs Back) and hence will be adding to traffic going west through the Hickley traffic lights before doing a U turn round the Coxbridge roundabout reducing traffic flow there.

    Likewise, lorries exiting the construction site, including fully laden ones with excavated material, will be turning onto the A31 carriageway directly, there is no acceleration lane.

    They will be trying to get into the right hand lane for the Shepherd and Flock to get onto the Hogs Back.

    So from a standing start on an uphill slope at a give way they will be trying to pick up speed and change lane whilst traffic comes at them from the traffic lights.

    At peak there is going to be up to 1 lorry every 4 minutes.

    Only some of the construction traffic is planned to use the bridge.

    The rest is going to be using 3 alternate routes including coming into Farnham on the Guildford Road and exiting on the Hale Road.

    This will be in addition to any construction traffic doing the same for the Woolmead site.

    And the latest estimates seem to envisage a 4 year construction period rather than the 2.5 to 3 previously proposed.

    Construction workers arriving on site will also add to traffic coming into Farnham itself.

    We can only hope that some regular drivers who currently use the A31 will be able to change routes or vary journey times.

    1. Thank you for your feedback incorporating the detailed information . Myles Harfield’s comments are no longer available but we would say that there is so much information that could have been included in the first film. Our intention was for it to be balanced, neutral and un-biased which we believe we achieved. The next couple of weeks when a lane on the A31 is closed will illustrate the true impact on Farnham.

    2. Thank you for your feedback incorporating the detailed information . Myles Harfield’s comments are no longer available but we would say that there is so much information that could have been included in the first film. Our intention was for it to be balanced, neutral and un-biased which we believe we achieved. The next couple of weeks when a lane on the A31 is closed will illustrate the true impact on Farnham.
      Thanks again
      David Howell

Comments are closed.